top of page

FIX CAPITALISM.
FIX THE AMERICAN DREAM.

Agree? Join in!

Search

Golden or Gilded: The Next American Age

Karen Kuykendall

In the world of metals, gold holds a unique position. It is beautiful, useful, non-corrosive, and rare--a combination of qualities so highly prized that its name is commonly used to signify something of incredible value. Think of how many of our sayings refer to this element: a golden moment, silence is golden, and heart of gold, among many others.


When a period of history is declared to be a "golden age," it's normally done by someone looking back at an outstanding time of achievement in the past. Since our President has recently reversed this model by announcing that we are at the beginning of a new golden age, I thought I'd ask AI if one could be announced ahead of time. The answer was as follows:


 No, you cannot simply "declare" a golden age; it is a term used to describe a historical period characterized by significant peace, prosperity, and cultural achievement, which is determined by historians based on evidence and analysis, not personal declarations. 


Now I know that AI is not always correct, but I do know what the norm is in this situation. As we cannot call an era "golden" before it has happened, our best option is to look at some of these historical periods and then compare them to our current state. So without further ado, let's look at a few golden ages and see what they have in common. We will focus briefly on three: Classical Greece, the Golden Age of Islam, and the European Renaissance.


© Marinos Karafyllidis via Canva.com


Past Golden Ages

The golden age of Greece, often referred to as the Classical period, is a remarkable era that spanned roughly from the 5th to the 4th century BCE, primarily centered in the city-state of Athens. This period is characterized by extraordinary advancements in various fields such as philosophy, art, architecture, and democracy, which laid the groundwork for Western civilization as we know it today.


During this time, Athens emerged as a powerful city-state, and its influence spread throughout the Mediterranean region. As opposed to monarchies that ruled the rest of the world, the political structure of Athens evolved into a form of direct democracy. An assembly known as the Ekklesia actively participated in the decision making process by gathering to discuss and vote on important matters of the day.


Philosophy also flourished during this time, with great thinkers such as Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle shaping the intellectual landscape. Together, they contributed the Socratic method, works like The Republic, and advanced knowledge to numerous fields including ethics, politics, metaphysics, and natural sciences, establishing a foundation for future scholarly pursuits.


In the realm of art and architecture, this age witnessed the creation of some of the most iconic structures and masterpieces that continue to inspire awe today. The Parthenon, a temple dedicated to the goddess Athena, exemplifies the architectural brilliance of the time. Sculptors produced breathtaking statues that celebrated the human form and depicted both gods and mortals, emphasizing ideals of beauty, proportion, and harmony.


Literature also thrived during this period, with playwrights making significant contributions to the development of tragedy and comedy. Their works explored complex themes of fate, morality, and human experience, often reflecting the societal values and challenges of their time. The theater became a central aspect of Athenian culture, serving not only as entertainment but also as a means of social commentary and political discourse.



Similarly, the Islamic Golden Age, which spanned from the 8th to the 14th century, was a time when scholars made remarkable contributions to mathematics, astronomy, medicine, and philosophy. This period saw the establishment of educational institutions that produced

an astonishing number of advancements during a time when much of the world's population was preoccupied with basic survival.

At the center of learning was the House of Wisdom in Baghdad, a place of scholarship that not only served as a library but also as a hub for intellectual discourse, translation, and scientific research. Scholars from diverse backgrounds congregated here, exchanging ideas and collaborating on various fields of study. Their research led to the development of algebra and the introduction of Arabic numerals, which revolutionized numerical representation and calculations.


In addition to mathematics, the House of Wisdom was instrumental in the field of astronomy. Scholars meticulously observed the stars, leading to improved astronomical tables and the refinement of models to understand planetary movements. This study laid the groundwork for future astronomers who would build upon these early observations.


This era saw significant contributions to medicine as well. Physicians and scholars translated and expanded upon the works of ancient Greek and Roman medical texts, leading to a deeper understanding of human anatomy and the development of surgical techniques. Pioneering figures emerged, producing influential writings that would be referenced for centuries in both the Islamic world and Europe.


Advancements in philosophy and the natural sciences were also achieved during this time. Philosophers engaged in critical discussions about ethics, metaphysics, and the nature of knowledge, drawing from both Islamic thought and ancient Greek philosophy. The flourishing of literature, with works like One Thousand and One Nights, showcased the rich storytelling traditions of the time as well.



Finally, the European Renaissance, marked a profound transformation in various aspects of society, culture, art, and intellectual thought that had a lasting impact on Europe and the world. This period, which spanned roughly from the 14th to the 17th century, was characterized by a resurgence of interest in the classical learning and values of ancient Greece and Rome. Scholars, artists, and thinkers began to explore new ideas and rediscover ancient texts, leading to significant advancements in numerous fields.


One of the most notable features of the Renaissance was the flourishing of the arts. Artists such as Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo, and Raphael produced masterpieces that showcased not only technical skill but also a deep understanding of human emotion and the natural world. The use of advanced techniques transformed painting and sculpture into profound expressions of human experience. These artistic innovations reflected a broader cultural shift towards humanism, which emphasized the value of individual experience and the potential for human achievement.


The Renaissance was a time of remarkable progress in science and philosophy. Thinkers like Galileo and Copernicus challenged long-held beliefs about the universe, laying the groundwork for modern science. The invention of the printing press revolutionized the dissemination of knowledge, making books more accessible and promoting literacy among the broader population. This technological advancement facilitated the spread of new ideas and encouraged critical thinking, which were essential components of the Renaissance spirit.


In addition, this time was marked by significant developments in literature. Writers such as Dante Alighieri, Petrarch, and William Shakespeare explored themes of love, politics, and the human condition, producing works that are still celebrated today. Their contributions not only enriched the literary landscape but also influenced the evolution of language and thought across Europe.


The Renaissance also had profound implications for society and politics. The rise of powerful city-states, particularly in Italy, fostered an environment where art and culture could thrive. Patronage from wealthy families allowed artists and thinkers to pursue their work without the constraints often imposed by feudal systems. This period saw the emergence of new political ideas, including concepts of governance and civic responsibility, which would later influence modern democratic thought.


While varied in their specifics, these three historical periods share common threads of innovation, cultural richness, and the pursuit of knowledge. During each one, we see not only greater peace and prosperity, but also advancements in the sciences, the arts, and governance. Each era, with its unique contributions, has left its mark on human history, advancing civilization and shaping the world we live in today.



Gilded v. Golden

Being rare and highly valued, real gold is very expensive; so throughout history, people have sought to give the impression of gold without the cost by gilding (applying a thin layer of a golden metallic substance) various surfaces. While beautiful to look at, the color is superficial and hides a material of much lower value.


Just as a gilded surface is not what it seems, the American Gilded Age may look deceptively like a golden one at first. This period covered the 1870s to around 1900 and was characterized by rapid economic growth, significant industrialization, and profound social change. It was marked by the proliferation of new technologies that transformed the American landscape and economy. The nation witnessed a dramatic shift from an agrarian society to an industrial powerhouse, with cities swelling as people flocked to urban centers in search of employment opportunities.


During this time, the country experienced the emergence of powerful industrialists and entrepreneurs, often referred to as "captains of industry" or, in a more critical light, "robber barons." Figures such as John D. Rockefeller in the oil industry, Andrew Carnegie in steel, and J.P. Morgan in finance played pivotal roles in shaping the economy. Their business practices often led to monopolies and trusts that dominated their respective sectors, raising concerns about fair competition and the ethical implications of their wealth accumulation.


Socially, the era was characterized by stark inequalities. While the wealthy elite enjoyed opulent lifestyles, complete with lavish mansions and extravagant social events, the working class often lived in overcrowded tenements with poor sanitation and limited access to healthcare. The era was also characterized by political corruption and patronage, as powerful political machines and party bosses wielded considerable influence over local and national politics.


Though I was unaware of it before writing this post, some scholars have designated the 1980s through the early 2000s as a Second American Gilded Age. Characterized by a remarkable transformation in the nation’s economy, these decades were marked by significant technological advancements and a dramatic increase in wealth concentration among a small elite.


During that time, the rise of the technology sector played a pivotal role in driving economic growth. Innovations in computing, telecommunications, and the internet revolutionized not only how businesses operated but also how individuals interacted with one another and accessed information. This period was also marked by rising economic inequality. A small percentage of the population amassed unprecedented wealth, often referred to as the "one percent," while a significant number of Americans faced stagnant wages and diminishing opportunities for upward mobility.


In addition to economic changes, the Second Gilded Age was characterized by shifts in political dynamics. Largely as a result of the landmark Supreme Court case, Citizens United v FEC, the influence of money in politics became increasingly pronounced, with corporations and wealthy individuals holding significant power over political processes through lobbying and campaign contributions.


The last part of the 20th century also saw the rise of consumerism, driven by aggressive marketing strategies and the availability of new products. The expansion of shopping malls, retail outlets, and brand culture reflected a shift in societal values towards consumption and material success.


In observing our present circumstances, I and many others believe we are still living in this Second Gilded Age, based on the description above. Except for the fact that shopping has moved online, all of the issues mentioned are still in play. In 2025, we continue to see the dominance of technology, consumerism, huge wealth inequality, and the outsized influence of big money in politics.


So how does a gilded age differ from a golden one? Primarily, golden ages are characterized by lasting achievements that (eventually) benefit everyone. Though they may have affected only a small number of people at the time, the ideas and advancements made during those periods--scientific breakthroughs, artistic and intellectual developments, and democracy--were expanded and eventually made many people's lives better. The achievements of a gilded age, on the other hand, seem mostly focused on building the net worth of a few and leaving everyone else behind.


The Future

A new American golden age, truthfully, would focus on correcting the current disparities and putting us all on a path toward a more mutually beneficial society (the Golden Rule!). It would concentrate on strengthening democracy, developing truly beneficial technologies, supporting the arts and education, and working toward peace with other countries.


It would also facilitate the growth of the middle class and the protection of those who are vulnerable. The leaders of this new American golden age would do these things not as a form of charity, but with the understanding that a better educated, better cared for, and more prosperous citizenry benefits everyone.


Will the next few years live up to these ideals? Only time will tell, but there will need to be more than the offering of a gold visa for wealthy immigrants, metallic high-top sneakers, and gilded crypto coins to earn this coveted title.


Fix Capitalism. Fix the American Dream.
Fix Capitalism. Fix the American Dream.

 




Buy now, or get a free sample here >>


"This book merits close, sustained attention as a compelling move beyond both careless thinking and easy ideology."—Walter Brueggemann, Columbia Theological Seminary


"Better Capitalism is a sincere search for a better world."—Cato Institute

 


Commenti


bottom of page